Acidic conditions are a challenge. If you want to produce hydrogen by electrolysis and use a low-cost catalyst such as cobalt, the process doesn’t function as well if the aqueous environment is acidic – working in alkaline conditions is easier. Researchers at the Paul Scherrer Institute PSI have now discovered the reason for this: the surface of the catalyst changes with the pH value of the environment. Their study, published in the journal Nature Chemistry, provides important clues to enable efficient and cost-effective production of hydrogen for the energy transition in the future.
The simplest and most environmentally friendly method for producing hydrogen is electrolysis: with an electric current, water (H2O) is split into its components, hydrogen (H2 ) and oxygen (O2). Oxygen is produced at the positive pole, the anode; hydrogen is produced at the negative pole, the cathode. Water splitting can be carried out in an alkaline environment (pH>7), an acidic one (pH<7), or a neutral one (pH=7). Different types of electrolysers operate at different pH values, that is, in different aqueous environments.
In splitting water, the formation of oxygen is the step that requires the most energy, effectively the bottleneck of the reaction. To make it possible to do this more efficiently and cost-effectively, catalysts such as the metal cobalt are used. However, electrolysis with cobalt only works satisfactorily in an alkaline environment; the reason for this was previously unknown.
A PSI research group in the Center for Energy and Environmental Sciences have now found out the cause: depending on the pH value, the catalyst’s surface changes. In acidic conditions, active sites where oxygen can be produced require more energy to form – as a result, electrolysis becomes slow and uneconomical. “We assume that this is the case not only with cobalt, but also with other metals that likewise perform less well in acidic conditions – such as manganese, iron, and nickel,” says Jinzhen Huang, a postdoctoral researcher in Emiliana Fabbri’s and Thomas Schmidt’s research group and first author of the study.
Cobalt as a low-cost alternative
At present, the noble metals iridium and ruthenium are usually used as catalysts for splitting water. Their activity changes only slightly depending on the pH value and therefore also work well in acidic environments. However, cobalt and other so-called transition metals are significantly cheaper and more abundant on Earth, which makes them particularly attractive for large-scale applications. “Replacing the noble metals with cobalt and other lower-cost metals is a major challenge,” Emiliana Fabbri explains. “Our findings are important steps on the way to that goal.”
Read more on PSI website
Image: Close-up of a glass vial containing a cobalt-based catalyst powder, captured in the lab at the Paul Scherrer Institute PSI. Researchers at the PSI Center for Energy and Environmental Sciences have discovered why this catalyst performs more efficiently in alkaline environments during hydrogen production.
Credit: Paul Scherrer Institute PSI/Mahir Dzambegovic